Sunday, September 4, 2011

Do You Mean "Dump Joe West?"

By Amy McCormick

I shouldn’t really be surprised, should I?  Especially considering the fact that Facebook reminded me a few days ago that my status a year before was “[My daughter] could do a better job as an ump, and she’s in diapers.  And nonverbal.  And legally blind.”

A year later, Olivia is a chatterbox, her vision has improved somewhat, and the potty issue is a work in progress.  One thing remains the same, though: she seems to think she can do what she wants and make up rules as she goes along.  Sound familiar?

Today’s game at Sun Life Stadium (“a dump,” according to Ricky Bo, and I concur) wasn’t much to talk about … until the top of the sixth.  Hunter Pence would have been out had it not been for fan interference.  That call should have been made on the spot; Joe West should have been able to say that Petersen would have made the catch easily, send Howard back to first, and move on.

Instead, West chose to gather the ump crew and watch instant replay.  Upon review, West sent Pence back to the dugout and Howard back to first base.  While this was the correct call, West used improper means to come to that conclusion.  Instant replay in baseball is for close homerun balls, which this clearly was not.

Enter Charlie Manuel.

In true Charlie style, he let everyone know something: The Marlins might be 28.5 games behind and will be watching October baseball from their living rooms, but Philadelphia does not tolerate nonsense from umpires.  On his way out (don’t act surprised that Charlie got tossed), he was sure to let West know that the Phils would continue to play under protest.  Essentially, no one is contesting the judgment call – Pence should have been out.  What is unacceptable is the blatant misuse of the instant replay.

I’m eager to hear postgame statements, and it will be interesting to see how things play out.  If Joe West says that he looked at the footage because he thought it could have been a homerun, then he’ll be insulting our intelligence. 

Two side notes … 1) Phils-Marlins games should never go into extras.  Period.  They’re the Marlins. 2) I Googled “ump joe west” and my computer asked me, “Do you mean dump joe west?” Maybe it’s time we started taking Google’s suggestions.



No comments:

Post a Comment